Old Pelican Bay Homes for Sale

Welcome to Old Pelican Bay, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, Florida. This charming community offers a perfect blend of tranquility and coastal living, making it an ideal place for anyone looking to embrace the beauty of Southwest Florida. With its picturesque landscapes and proximity to the stunning Gulf of Mexico, Old Pelican Bay stands out as a premier destination for both relaxation and recreation.

The homes for sale in Old Pelican Bay are as diverse as they are captivating. From cozy beach cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, there’s a property to suit every lifestyle and preference. Each home is thoughtfully designed to maximize comfort and style, featuring spacious layouts, modern amenities, and often, breathtaking views of the surrounding natural beauty. Imagine waking up to the sound of gentle waves and enjoying your morning coffee on a sun-drenched patio, or hosting family and friends in your beautifully landscaped backyard.

In addition to the stunning homes, residents of Old Pelican Bay enjoy easy access to Fort Myers Beach's vibrant community. Nearby, you’ll find an array of dining options, boutique shops, and outdoor activities, including boating, fishing, and sunbathing on pristine sandy shores. With a friendly atmosphere and a strong sense of community, Old Pelican Bay is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle.

Explore the available homes for sale in Old Pelican Bay today and discover the perfect sanctuary where coastal charm meets modern living. Your dream home awaits!

Newest Old Pelican Bay Homes for Sale

$1,275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026025498 MLS

Welcome to 12205 Siesta Drive, the ultimate boating and fishing community located on an oversized southern exposure 1.5-lot parcel in the secure, gated enclave of Old Pelican Bay in Fort Myers Beach, the Boater & Fisherman's Paradise. With it's bonus rooms, the home offers over 2300 sq ft of living space under air. This property features one of the deepest, quickest Gulf-access canal locations in Southwest Florida with zero bridge restrictions. Fire up the engines and be in the Gulf in minutes, or head to the Keys and Bahamas. Walk down your private path and step onto your boat. Your private end-unit dock slip features a raised pedestal for dedicated electric and water, easily accommodating a deep-draft yacht up to 48 feet or a heavy-duty lift. Located on the naturally deep East canal, you will never face shallow water or expensive dredging bills. Built to support a marine lifestyle, this oversized 1.5-lot parcel offers plenty of room to add a custom pool and spa, with utility hookups in place. An enclosed, lockable storage shed comes equipped with a dedicated electrical subpanel—perfect for stashing rods, tackle, nets, and diving gear. Tough mechanical upgrades keep maintenance low, including a durable metal roof, private elevator, dual-zone AC, and a central vacuum system. Inside, find refined details including 9-foot ceilings, 3rd-floor cathedral ceilings, crown molding, plantation shutters, and gorgeous, rich maple cabinetry. Over $135k in upgrades and generous credits includes a huge $27,000 cash credit to the buyer at closing. This covers a brand-new appliance package ($6k), new flooring/carpet ($5k), and new 2nd-floor PGT hurricane windows ($16k). Combined with existing 3rd-floor impact glass and motorized storm shutters, the home is built like a fortress. Outside, beautiful Areca palms, Ficus hedges, and a custom 12V landscape lighting system create a magnificent private nighttime oasis. Spend your time on the water, not doing yard work. A weekly landscape crew handles all lawn cutting and edging. Low HOA fees ($429/month) cover your complete lawn care and the community's state-of-the-art security gate, complete with a license plate reader and contractor call-in office.

12205 Siesta Drive, Fort Myers Beach

$959,990

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026016049 MLS

OWNER FINANCING AVAILABLE! MOTIVATED SELLER! The best of both worlds: minutes to the beach without island traffic, and one of the shortest boating runs to open Gulf waters in the entire region. This Key West style home delivers the Fort Myers Beach lifestyle without the congestion, bridges, and premium pricing of island property. Located in the highly desirable Old Pelican Bay area, this is a true single family home, NOT a duplex or shared wall property, offering far superior privacy, long term value, and exceptional boating access. And take note of the aggressive pricing. In fact, a very similar home directly across the street recently sold for considerably more, look it up. It only confirms that this one is a deal. Boaters will love the fact this comes with not one but TWO deeded boat slips, a rare combination for the Fort Myers Beach area. One is 40 feet long with a boat lift already in place, plus there is an additional 25 foot slip as well. The boating run to open Gulf waters is truly among the shortest in the region, making this an ideal location for serious boaters. The rear of the property is superb as well, overlooking uninterrupted scenic mangroves that provide natural views, privacy, and spectacular sunset vistas, especially from the private primary suite. The gated neighborhood is great too, exceptionally well maintained and perfect for those who put an emphasis on a low maintenance lifestyle that they can easily come and go to whenever they please, yet with modest HOA fees. This home features a two story screened pool enclosure with a heated saltwater pool and spa. The first floor offers an inviting bar and bonus space right off the pool, perfect for entertaining. The second floor features an open layout with a distinctive kitchen, large island, and wine cooler, plus a 22 foot wide balcony overlooking the pool and mangroves. The third floor is dedicated to the primary suite, complete with an impressive bathroom and a private terrace for enjoying those sunsets. A private elevator services all floors. The metal roof is brand new, the pool has been resurfaced, a high end marble pool deck has been added, and top of the line AC systems are additional perks. The Old Pelican area is rapidly becoming even more desirable, with new homes now starting at four times the cost of this home and some going even higher, but here is your opportunity to buy into this premium location for a fraction of that price. Come check this one out quickly. Be sure to view the virtual tour for larger format photos, detailed floorplans, and a great 3D walkthrough to fully explore the layout of this truly impressive home. EASY TO SEE!

12220 Siesta Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Start Your Search